• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Stephanie's Italian Restaurant

**About Stephanie's Italian Restaurant**

Nestled in Caldwell, NJ, Stephanie's Italian Restaurant offers an authentic Italian dining experience characterized by exceptional food and warm service. Renowned for its delightful menu, this cozy eatery captures the essence of Italy with dishes like lobster ravioli and arugula salad, all crafted from fresh, high-quality ingredients. The BYOB policy enhances the casual charm, making it perfect for date nights or gatherings with friends. Manager Michelle Iansito ensures every visit exceeds expectations, while the beautiful outdoor seating adds a touch of elegance. With rave reviews highlighting great flavors and friendly staff, Stephanie's invites diners to savor true Italian hospitality.

Stephanie's Italian Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings

Judith Henderson
Judith Henderson

Stephanie‘s has excellent food at reasonable prices. Manager Michelle Iansito provides excellent service—efficient, friendly, and very willing to ensure customer satisfaction. I am a lifelong diner in differing types of restaurants in US and abroad, and I would go the extra mile to eat here!

David G.
David G.

I have not been to Stephanie's since about 2008. This Friday night I went with my buddies. All around, great food, great service , great desserts. Byob. The Italian food was true authentic Italian food. We had lots of appetizers, and all were delicious. You can order the appetizers' family style, so we did. There was not one thing bad about this restaurant. We had 9 people. This restaurant is perfect for date night, family night , or a night with your friends. FABULOUS!

Alexis Callie
Alexis Callie

Great little place for Italian food, byob. I’ve been going here for years and it doesn’t disappoint! Update: went back again this past weekend and ITS STILL SO GOOD!

Chrystia Woroch
Chrystia Woroch

We dined outside which is decorated beautifully. Staff is wonderful. The food is fabulous.. we shared the arugula salad special, I had the lobster raviolis, my friend had scallop and crab stuffing special, I finished with the berries w/ cream.. make reservations! BYOB..

Nicole Schaefer
Nicole Schaefer

Just wow! Food was spectacular. Very distinct, amazing flavors. All fresh. Went here on new years eve. It was packed for a reason. This was my first time definitely going back! Everyone was so nice. It's BYOB.

jerzc nate
jerzc nate

Let me start with this we were at Fat Fish and saw Stephanie's sign. Not one time but two times we see the sign. We go to Google look at the pics, reviews and menu. Stephanie's is a place go and so freaking glad we did. One it's not a restaurant it's your kitchen and your dining room. Why I say that cause it's cozy yet elegant. You feel at home once you step in that's an awesome feeling and they nailed it. Stephanie's is a BYOB and our amazing server Ms. Michelle was tremendous. Warm bread comes to the table with butter and flavored olive oil. Ms. Stephanie's tells us the appetizer specials I guess. Wife ordered the fresh mozzarella with roasted peppers and tomatoes. Stuffed rice balls with beef and cheese in a vodka sauce also ordered. Ms. Michelle told us the specials which to our surprise we ordered from the special. Maryland blue crab stuffed ravioli in a vodka sauce is what my Wife ordered. I on the other hand ordered flounder stuffed with crab on sauteed spinach in a lemon sauce. Hot AMN that flounder dish had my complete focus. Seasoned perfect the flounder was the lemon sauce with a touch of fresh garlic. Man Chef you put your foot in that meal. Stuffed and happy my Wife and I were. Ms. Michelle awesome server Chef phenomenal Stephanie's is a World Class Italian Restaurant

Brittany Matthes
Brittany Matthes

The food was amazing! The portions are huge and the food is so fresh!!! The prices are great too! Such a homey feeling inside! Definitely coming back!!

Glenn Rothman
Glenn Rothman

I had a delightful diner with my wife last Saturday night. We were greeted warmly upon arrival and seated promptly. The dinning room is cozy and the crowd is neighborhood friendly. I ordered the flounder francaise which was absolutely delicious. My wife enjoyed tuna over broccoli rabe. The food was excellent and portions were very generous (we enjoyed leftovers the next day). Service was professional and attentive. All I all a great experience

Location

Welcome to Stephanie's Italian Restaurant, a hidden gem located in the heart of Caldwell, New Jersey, at 283 Bloomfield Ave. This charming establishment invites you to indulge in authentic Italian cuisine while basking in a warm and welcoming atmosphere.

Renowned for its excellent food and reasonable prices, Stephanie's has garnered a loyal following. Customers rave about the exceptional service, with manager Michelle Iansito leading the team to ensure satisfaction. Reviewers have highlighted the efficient and friendly service, which perfectly complements the vibrant dining experience.

Step inside, and you will be greeted by a delightful culinary voyage. The restaurant excels in offering true Italian dishes, crafted with fresh ingredients and an abundance of flavor. Diners can't stop talking about their generous family-style appetizers, which add to the communal spirit of sharing a meal with loved ones. From the arugula salad special to the decadent lobster raviolis, each dish is prepared with meticulous care and attention.

Don't forget to save room for dessert! Guests have praised the fabulous sweet offerings that round out their meals beautifully. Given the BYOB policy, guests can truly customize their dining experience, bringing along their favorite wines to enhance their meal even further.

As Judith Henderson notes, "I would go the extra mile to eat here!" This sentiment resonates deeply with me after savoring every moment spent dining at Stephanie's. Each bite transports you to Italy, wrapped in tradition and taste. Whether you're planning a romantic evening, a family gathering, or a casual night out with friends, Stephanie's Italian Restaurant is the perfect destination.

Make your reservation today and embark on a culinary adventure that promises to leave a lasting impression. Experience why locals and visitors alike are enchanted by the flavors and hospitality at Stephanie's. You won't be disappointed.