Stephanie's Italian Restaurant Menu

Welcome to Stephanie's Italian Restaurant, a hidden gem nestled in Caldwell, NJ. This charming eatery is celebrated for its authentic Italian cuisine and inviting atmosphere. Guests rave about the exceptional service provided by manager Michelle Iansito, who ensures every visit is delightful and satisfying.

Whether you're indulging in lobster ravioli or sharing family-style appetizers, the menu showcases a variety of flavorful dishes crafted with fresh ingredients. Diners often commend the BYOB policy, making it a flexible choice for any occasion—from cozy date nights to lively gatherings with friends.

  • Signature dishes: Lobster ravioli, arugula salad special
  • Ambiance: Beautiful outdoor seating
  • Customer satisfaction: Consistently high praise for food and service

Join the many guests who return for the fabulous flavors and unforgettable dining experience at Stephanie's.

Dinner - Salads

MESCALIN SALAD

Baby greens tossed with carrots, red onions, tomatoes and our homemade dressing

US$12.99

CAESAR SALAD

Romaine lettuce tossed with croutons, grated cheese and our homemade creamy Caesar dressing

US$13.99

Spinach Salad

Spinach tossed with tomatoes, black olives and our homemade creamy Gorgonzola dressing

US$13.99

ARUGALA & TOMATO SALAD

Arugula tossed with tomatoes and our homemade dressing

US$12.99

FENNEL SALAD

Fennel tossed with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, red onions, arugula and black olives in a white balsamic vinaigrette

US$14.99

STRINGBEAN SALAD

String beans tossed with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, red onions and black olives in a balsamic vinaigrette dressing

US$14.99

TRI COLOR SALAD

Arugula, endive and radicchio tossed with tomatoes and our home made dressing

US$13.99

TOMATO & ONION SALAD

Tomatoes and red onions tossed with black olives and fresh mozzarella with a white balsamic vinaigrette dressing

US$14.99

TOASTED ALMOND

US$9.99

TIRAMISU

US$9.99

NY CHEESECAKE

US$11.99

CHOCOLATE LAYER CAKE

US$10.99

CANNOLI

US$7.99

Dinner Desserts

Dinner - Entrees

VEAL CHOP MILENESE W/SHAVED PARM

Breaded Veal Chop topped with arugula, radicchio, endive, diced tomatoes and shaved parmigiana cheese

US$36.99

CHICKEN SALTIMBOCCA

Chicken scaloppini topped with prosciutto and provolone, served over a bed of spinach in a demi glaze sauce

US$25.99

Calamari Marinara Over Cappellini

Calamari sauteed with onions, herbs and wine in a light tomato sauce over capellini

US$27.99

CHICKEN FRANCESE

Egg dipped chicken in a lemon, wine and butter sauce over a bed of spinach

US$26.99

CHICKEN CALABRESE

Chicken scaloppini topped with asparagus, roasted red peppers, and provolone cheese in a light lemon vermouth sauce

US$25.99

BLACKENED SALMON

Served over broccoli rabe

US$27.99

ZUPPO DI PESCE MARCHIARO OVER PASTA

Clams, mussels, shrimp, scallops, calamari and flounder served in a light marinara sauce over pasta

US$37.99

SHRIMP STEPHANIE

Shrimp sauteed with artichokes hearts, sun dried tomatoes and shiitake mushrooms in a lemon wine sauce

US$27.99

CHICKEN MILANESE W SHAVED PARM

Breaded chicken cutlet with arugula, radicchio, endive, diced tomatoes and shaved parmigiana cheese

US$25.99

CHICKEN & SHRIMP FRANCES

Egg dipped shrimp and chicken in a lemon, wine and butter sauce over a bed of spinach

US$26.99

SALMON OREGANTA

Salmon topped with bread crumbs and seasonings in a lemon, wine and butter sauce served over a bed of spinach W/2 Shrimp

US$29.99

CHICKEN PICCATTA

Chicken scaloppini in a lemon, wine and butter sauce with capers

US$26.99

SHRIMP FRANCES

Egg dipped shrimp in a lemon, wine, butter sauce over a bed of spinach

US$28.99

CHICKEN GIAMBOTTA

Chicken sauteed with peppers, onions, mushrooms, sausage, and potatoes in a light demi glaze sauce

US$25.99

SCALLOPS TRE FUNGHI

Scallops sauteed with three mushrooms in light marsala cream sauce

US$34.99

CHICKEN SAVOY

Chicken scaloppini with garlic, wine and balsamic vinegar

US$26.99

SALMON GRILLED

Grilled salmon served on a bed of broccoli rabe

US$27.99

CHICKEN MARSALA

Chicken scaloppini with mushrooms in a marsala sauce

US$26.99

FLOUNDER FRANCES

Egg dipped flounder in a lemon, wine and butter sauce over a bed of spinach

US$26.99

CHICKEN SORRENTINO

Chicken scaloppini topped with prosciutto, eggplant, sliced tomato, provolone cheese in a light brown sauce

US$27.99

Veal Chop Parmigiana

Breaded veal chop in a light tomato sauce, topped with melted mozzarella

US$36.99

CHICKEN PAILLARD

Grilled chicken topped with sauteed sweet peppers and mushrooms

US$25.99

Shrimp Parmigiana

Breaded shrimp in a light tomato sauce, topped with melted mozzarella

US$26.99

Chicken Parmigiana

Breaded chicken cutlet in a light tomato sauce, topped with melted mozzarella

US$24.99

Eggplant Parmigiana

Breaded eggplant in a light tomato sauce, topped with melted mozzarella

US$23.99

FLOUNDER OREGANATA

Flounder topped with bread crumbs and seasonings in a lemon, wine and butter sauce served over a bed of spinach W /2 Shrimp

US$28.99

EGGPLANT ROLLATINI

Sliced eggplant filled with ricotta cheese in a light tomato sauce, topped with mozzarella

US$23.99

CHICKEN TRE FUNGHI

chicken scaloppini with assorted mushrooms in a marsala wine demi glaze with a touch of cream

US$26.99

CAVATELLI SORRENTINO

Pasta with fresh mozzarella in a fresh tomato sauce

US$23.99

CHEESE RAVIOLI

Cheese filled pasta in marinara sauce

US$20.99

FUSSILI BOLOGNESE

Home made spiral pasta with meat sauce and a touch of cream

US$24.99

FUSSILI BARESI

Home made spiral pasta with broccoli rabe and sausage in a light garlic and oil

US$24.99

RIGATONI VODKA

Rigatoni with herbs in a light pink vodka sauce

US$22.99

FIOCCHI

Pasta pouches filled with pear and cheese in a white wine and shallots sauce

US$23.99

FETTUCINI ALFREDO

Pasta in a creamy alfredo sauce

US$22.99

FETTUCINI ALFREDO W SHRIMP

US$26.99

RIGATONI SICILIANO

Pasta with eggplant , mozzarella and tomato sauce

US$22.99

SPAGHETTI CARBONARA CON GAMBERI

Pasta with peas, pancetta, shrimp, onions in a creamy Alfredo sauce

US$26.99

LASAGNA W/ MEATBALLS

Homemade with cheese, ricotta and a marinara sauce W 2 Meatballs

US$24.99

BAKED PENNE

Pasta in our marinara sauce baked with mozzarella

US$20.99

TORTELINI BOLOGNESE

Cheese filled tortellini in a creamy meat sauce

US$24.99

GNOCCHI ROMANO

Potato Dumplings with prosciutto, peas, mushrooms in a light pink cream sauce

US$22.99

LINGUINI STEPHANIE

Pasta with spinach and shrimp in a fresh tomato sauce

US$26.99

PENNE VODKA

Penne with herbs in a light pink vodka sauce

US$22.99

LOBSTER RAVIOLI

Lobster filled pasta topped with vodka sauce

US$23.99

CAPPELLINI POMODORO

Pasta with fresh tomato, onion and basil

US$22.99

PASTA MARINARA

Pasta in our homemade marinara sauce

US$18.99

CAPPELINI PRIMAVERA

Pasta with carrots, broccoli, zucchini and peas with light pink cream sauce

US$22.99

PENNE BARESI

Penne pasta with broccoli rabe and sausage in a light garlic and oil

US$23.99

FETTUCINI CALABRESE

Pasta with jumbo shrimp, shiitake mushrooms, sun dried tomatoes in a light creamy pesto sauce

US$26.99

CAPPELINI VENTIMIGLIA

Pasta with a light marinara sauce made with artichoke hearts, prosciutto and sliced olives

US$22.99

Dinner - Pasta

TAKE OUT SAUCES/SOUPS

Bolognese Sauce(Pint)

US$7.99

Chicken Soup (Pint)

US$6.99

HOUSE Salad Dressings (Quart)

US$10.99

Marinara Sauce (Quart)

US$12.99

Bolognese Sauce (Quart)

US$14.99

Vodka Sauce (Quart)

US$14.99

HOUSE Salad Dressings (Pint)

US$7.99

Marinara Sauce (Pint)

US$6.99

Chicken Soup (Quart)

US$12.99

Vodka Sauce (Pint)

US$7.99

50 Gift

US$50.00

200 Gift

US$200.00

150 Gift

US$150.00

25 Gift

US$25.00

100 Gift

US$100.00

75 Gift

US$75.00

Gift Card

NEW YEARS EVE MENU

CHICKEN MILANESE W SHAVED PARM

Breaded chicken cutlet with arugula, radicchio, endive, diced tomatoes and shaved parmigiana cheese

US$25.99

BLACKENED SALMON

Served over broccoli rabe

US$27.99

SAUTEED SPINACH

US$10.99

ZUPPA DI MUSSLES

US$16.99

MOZZARELLA IN CORROZZA

US$9.99

SAUTEED BROCCOLI

US$10.99

ZUPPA DI CLAMS

US$16.99

COLD ANTIPASTO

US$18.99

FRIED ZUCCHINI

US$14.99

SIDE OF MEATBALLS

US$9.99

Fresh Mozzarella With Roasted Peppers & Tomato

US$14.99

SAUTEED BROC RABE

US$13.99

SIDE FRENCH FRIES

US$8.99

SAUTEED STRINGBEANS

US$10.99

GARLIC BREAD

US$5.99

Roasted Potatoes

US$8.99

SIDE OF SAUSAGE

US$9.99

BABY SHRIMP ARRIBIATTA APPT

US$18.99

FRIED CALAMARI

US$17.99

Eggplant Roll Appt

US$10.99

BRUSCHETTA

US$14.99

CLAMS OREGANATA

US$15.99

Dinner - Appetizers